Vegetable and Herb Flowers

Which mint is not edible?

Most true mints are edible, but pennyroyal is best avoided, and some plants called mint aren't mints at all. Here's how to tell what is safe to eat.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. Pennyroyal
  3. Essential oils are not the same as the leaf
  4. Plants called “mint” that are not culinary mints
  5. How to be sure
  6. Pregnancy and health
  7. Flowers

Short answer

Most plants in the true mint genus (Mentha), such as peppermint, spearmint, apple mint and chocolate mint, are edible. The one to avoid eating is pennyroyal (Mentha pulegium). Beyond that, the risk is mostly in misidentifying a plant: some plants have “mint” in their common name but are not culinary mints, and wild mint-family plants can be hard to tell apart.

Pennyroyal

Pennyroyal is a low-growing mint with small round leaves and lilac flowers, often found in damp ground. It has a strong minty smell. It has been used historically as a flavouring and as a folk remedy, but it contains a compound called pulegone that is toxic, and it is generally advised not to eat it or take it as a tea or oil. Pennyroyal oil in particular is dangerous, and pennyroyal is specifically not recommended during pregnancy. Thompson & Morgan’s edible flower list carries the same pregnancy warning.

If you grow it as a ground cover or to deter insects, label it clearly so nobody picks it for the kitchen.

Essential oils are not the same as the leaf

Eating fresh peppermint leaves is very different from swallowing concentrated peppermint oil. Essential oils are concentrated and are not intended for casual ingestion. Do not use any mint essential oil as a flavouring or tea unless it is specifically sold as food-grade and used as directed.

Plants called “mint” that are not culinary mints

Plenty of plants carry “mint” in their name without being edible mints, or are only distantly related. Some are in the mint family but not used for food, and others have nothing to do with it. Examples include ornamental plants sold as “mint bush”. If a plant is only labelled “mint” at a garden centre, check the botanical name.

Catmint (Nepeta) is a mint family plant and is edible in small amounts, but is mainly grown as an ornamental. See peppermint, catmint and perilla flowers for how to use it.

How to be sure

  • Check the botanical name. For true edible mints, look for Mentha species and hybrids that are sold as herbs.
  • Square stem and aroma. Mints have square stems and a strong, clearly minty smell when the leaf is crushed. No smell is a warning sign.
  • Buy from a trusted source. Herb plants sold for eating are the safest bet.
  • Don’t eat unidentified wild plants. The mint family also has look-alikes, and some plants in other families have similar leaves.
  • Avoid sprayed plants. Ornamentals and roadside plants may have been treated with chemicals.

Pregnancy and health

Mint leaves in food are generally considered fine for most people, but advice on herbal teas and large quantities varies. If you are pregnant, breastfeeding, take regular medication or have a condition such as acid reflux, ask a health professional about regular intake of mint teas.

Flowers

Flowers of true edible mints are edible too, with a strong minty flavour; they’re usually used in small amounts. As with the leaves, apply the same rules about identification and chemical-free plants. Also see the overview of vegetable and herb flowers.

The complete guide to vegetable and herb flowers

Edible Flowers from the Vegetable and Herb Garden
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →